Going to a Buffalo football game, one of the Autumn festivals, or out to see the Fall Foliage?  Driving in Buffalo, Hamburg, Orchard Park, West Seneca or Cheektowaga? Fresh-pressed apple cider, our secret recipe doughnuts, apple pies bursting with flavor and gourmet treats from all over Western New York are waiting for you at the Mayer Brothers Cider Mill and Bakery.

Step back in time each autumn and join us at the Ol’ Cider Mill store for some of the freshest baked goods in Western New York!

Enjoy apple cider, apple cider slushies, home style baked pies, donuts, candied apples, as well as other New York State products like jams, maple syrup, artisan cheese, and you never know what else!


Hours of Operation

We are officially open for the season! Open 7 Days a week, 6am->7pm!


Bakery Goods


Stop in for one of our all natural apple cider slushies or a great cup of Green Mountain coffee.

  • Pies, Donuts, and other Bakery Items made fresh daily
  • Fresh baked Apple Strudel
  • Placek, preservative free Fresh Pressed Cider, and other unique gourmet items

We carry many local and New York State products — i.e., jams, jellies, maple syrup, and candy (for that sweet tooth)


Share us on Facebook!




1540 Seneca Creek Rd @ Transit Road
West Seneca, NY
(716) 668-5260

Contact Us